I've spent a LOT of time playing with AI image tools since Adobe Firefly launched in 2023, when its generative fill caught the attention of creators across the globe.
Firefly has grown into a full creative app with Google's and OpenAI's models built in, and the tools competing with it have changed just as much.
So I've rebuilt this list: the 7 best Adobe Firefly alternatives for making and editing AI images, with what each one costs and how it handles Firefly-style generative fill.
Full disclosure: I earn a commission if you sign up to Leonardo through my links. Every tool here is judged on the same things.
🥇 Best overall#1
Midjourney
The best-looking AI images around, and its web Editor does generative fill (Vary Region) on Midjourney images and your own uploads.
Free, open-source software that runs image models like FLUX, Qwen Image and Stable Diffusion on your own computer, with inpainting and outpainting built in.
How do the best Adobe Firefly alternatives compare?
Here are the 7 best Adobe Firefly alternatives side by side, with Firefly itself at the bottom for reference. Prices are in US dollars.
Tool
Best for
Free option
Paid from
Firefly-style editing
Midjourney
Image quality
No
$10/month
Vary Region, on your own photos too
Leonardo
Value
150 tokens a day
$12/month ($10 yearly)
Canvas editor and Inline Editor
ChatGPT Images
Quick edits in chat
Yes, limited
Paid ChatGPT plans
Select an area and describe the change
Google Gemini
Free photo edits
Nano Banana 2
$4.99/month
Describe the change to any photo
Ideogram
Text, logos and posters
30 credits a week
$20/month ($15 yearly)
Select area and Extend (paid plans)
Canva
Social posts and ads
20 AI uses a month
$144/year
Magic Edit and Magic Expand
ComfyUI
Free, private image work
Free on your own PC
Cloud from $20/month
Built-in inpainting and outpainting
Adobe Firefly
Commercially safe images
Daily free generations
$9.99/month
Generative Fill and Generative Expand
How I picked the best Adobe Firefly alternatives
I judged every Firefly alternative on the same five things:
Image quality: how good are the images?
Generative fill: how well does it add, remove or change part of an image, including your own photos?
Control: can you tweak it until you get exactly what you want?
Ease of use: how long does it take to learn?
Cost: is there a free plan, and what does it cost to use properly?
To compare generative fill, I took the same photo and asked Midjourney, Leonardo and Adobe Firefly to add a neck tattoo with the same prompt.
Same photo, same prompt. Midjourney and Firefly got there within a few tries; Leonardo took me a good 15 minutes.
What are the best Adobe Firefly alternatives?
The best Adobe Firefly alternatives are Midjourney, Leonardo, ChatGPT Images, Google Gemini, Ideogram, Canva and ComfyUI. Midjourney is the best overall for image quality, Leonardo is the best value, Gemini is the best free option, and ComfyUI is the pick if you want free, open-source software on your own computer.
1. Midjourney
🥇 Best overall
Midjourney is still the best Adobe Firefly alternative for image quality. It can make basically anything you can think of, whether it's ultra-real stock photos, product logos, cartoon characters or professional food shots.
Created using Midjourney v5.1
Midjourney's Firefly-style tools live in its web Editor at midjourney.com. Vary Region erases part of an image and regenerates it from a prompt, and you can also pan, zoom out and upload your own photos to edit. The current V8.2 model, the default since July 2026, added an Edit model that changes images from written instructions (Midjourney).
Check out the image below. I generated it with Midjourney, then added a neck tattoo with Vary Region. The quality certainly gives Firefly a run for its money.
I created this image in Midjourney, then used Vary Region to add a neck tattoo.
Midjourney also has text-to-image, image prompts, image blending and Describe, which turns an uploaded image into a text prompt. Because it's so popular, there are heaps of resources to help you write better prompts, like my Midjourney cheat sheet.
Created using Midjourney v5.1
Midjourney pricing
Basic: $10/month for 3.3 hours (200 minutes) of fast generations.
Standard: $30/month for 15 hours of fast generations plus unlimited images in Relax mode.
Pro: $60/month for 30 hours of fast generations and Stealth Mode to keep your images private.
Mega: $120/month for 60 hours of fast generations and Stealth Mode.
Paying yearly takes 20% off every plan, and there's no free plan (Midjourney).
Best for
Image quality
Price
From $10/month; no free plan
Firefly-style editing
Vary Region in the web Editor
What I like
Some of the highest-quality AI images you can get
Vary Region works on your own uploaded photos, not just Midjourney images
Heaps of prompt guides and resources online
Watch out for
No free plan
Some people have ethical concerns about the images Midjourney was trained on
Leonardo is the best-value Adobe Firefly alternative, with a free plan, a huge range of models and its own take on generative fill. It's owned by Canva but still runs as its own product (Canva).
Alongside its own models like Phoenix and Lucid Origin, Leonardo gives you partner models such as Nano Banana, GPT Image and FLUX in the same app, so you can generate images in a huge range of styles.
When I first tested it, Leonardo's Alchemy and Prompt Magic v2 features made impressive 2D images like this one.
Leonardo's Canvas Editor is what makes it a proper Firefly alternative. You can extend, mask, replace and erase parts of an image, and regenerate specific areas until you get what you want. There's also an Inline Editor: open any image, type what you want changed, and Leonardo's Omni models make the edit, with up to six reference images depending on the model.
I used Leonardo's take on generative fill to remove the glasses.
You can also train your own custom models (Leonardo calls them Elements) on your own images, and Leonardo makes video and 3D too. I've covered every tool in my Leonardo AI review.
Leonardo pricing
Free: 150 fast tokens a day, enough to get a feel for Leonardo.
Essential: $12/month ($10/month billed yearly) for 8,500 fast tokens a month and private generations.
Premium: $30/month ($24/month billed yearly) for 25,000 fast tokens a month plus unlimited relaxed images on select models.
Ultimate: $60/month ($48/month billed yearly) for 60,000 fast tokens a month plus unlimited relaxed images and video on select models.
Best for
Value and editing tools
Price
Free plan; from $12/month ($10 yearly)
Firefly-style editing
Canvas editor and Inline Editor
What I like
Free plan with 150 tokens a day
The Canvas and Inline Editor cover most of what Generative Fill does
Partner models like Nano Banana and GPT Image in the same app
Watch out for
Can be overwhelming for new users
The Canvas editor takes a while to learn: my first inpaint took me about 15 minutes
ChatGPT Images is the easiest Adobe Firefly alternative if you already use ChatGPT, because it's built right in. It replaced DALL·E 3, which is what I originally tested for this list. OpenAI has since retired DALL·E 2 and DALL·E 3 altogether, and their API access ended in May 2026 (OpenAI).
The current version, ChatGPT Images 2.5, can create images from a prompt and edit them. Select part of an image with the selection tool and describe the change, or just describe the edit in chat. It works on your own uploaded photos too, which makes it a proper generative fill alternative (OpenAI).
Back when it was still DALL·E, I took a Midjourney puppy and used inpainting to give it a beanie. The results weren't bad, and these days you can do the same thing with one chat message.
A Midjourney puppy (left) and the same puppy with a beanie added by DALL·E (right).
ChatGPT Images pricing
Free: ChatGPT Images is included on the free ChatGPT plan, with limited image creation.
Paid: Go, Plus and Pro raise the limits, and Pro gets unlimited, faster image creation (ChatGPT pricing).
Best for
Quick edits in chat
Price
Free with limits; paid ChatGPT plans raise them
Firefly-style editing
Select an area and describe the change
What I like
Nothing new to learn if you already use ChatGPT
Keep refining an image just by describing more changes
Works on the web, iOS and Android
Watch out for
Selections aren't always precise, so edits can spill outside the area you highlighted
The free plan only gives you a limited number of images
Google Gemini is the best free Adobe Firefly alternative for quick photo edits, thanks to Google's image model, Nano Banana.
Upload a photo, tell Gemini what to change, and it makes the edit. You can swap a sunny day for a moody night, change the camera angle, restyle the whole image from a reference photo, or combine two photos into one (Google).
It's also good with text, so logos, posters and invites come out with clear, readable words in many languages.
Nano Banana 2 is free in the Gemini app, and Google AI plans unlock Nano Banana 2.1, Google's best image model, with higher limits. Adobe even offers Google's Nano Banana models inside Firefly and Photoshop's Generative Fill, which tells you how far it's come.
Google Gemini pricing
Free: Nano Banana 2 is free in the Gemini app.
Google AI Plus: $4.99/month for twice the usage of the free plan and access to Nano Banana 2.1.
Google AI Pro: $19.99/month for four times the usage of the free plan, plus Google's other premium AI features (Google).
Best for
Free photo edits
Price
Free; from $4.99/month
Firefly-style editing
Describe the change to any photo
What I like
The base Nano Banana model costs nothing
No learning curve: if you can describe it, you can edit it
Clear, readable text in many languages
Watch out for
Higher limits and Nano Banana 2.1, Google's best image model, need a paid Google AI plan
Ideogram is the Adobe Firefly alternative for anything with words in it, like posters, logos, thumbnails and social graphics. It made its name by getting text right in AI images back when most generators spelt everything wrong.
Ideogram's newest model, Ideogram 4.5, takes up to five reference images, which helps with photo editing, product photos, mockups and keeping a character consistent. Ideogram 3.0 is still the one for logos and brand graphics, because it's the only Ideogram model with style presets, style references and colour palettes. You also get partner models like GPT Image and Nano Banana (Ideogram).
Ideogram's editor, Studio, is where the Firefly-style tools are. It replaced the old Canvas and Magic Fill: paint over part of an image with Select area and describe the change, or use Extend to grow the canvas. You can upload your own JPG, PNG or WEBP photos, and Layerize text turns the words in an image into text layers you can edit (Ideogram).
I've put Ideogram up against Leonardo with the same prompts. Here's one of them: "a polaroid capture of high school lovers happy on the car bonnet, late 1960s America, flash photography".
Same prompt, Leonardo (left) and Ideogram (right).
Ideogram pricing
Free: 30 credits a week if you sign in with Google, Apple or Microsoft. Everything you make is public.
Plus: $20/month ($15/month billed yearly) for 2,400 credits a month and private images.
Pro: $60/month ($42/month billed yearly) for 7,500 credits a month and batch generation (Ideogram).
Best for
Posters, logos and thumbnails
Price
Free plan; from $20/month ($15 yearly)
Firefly-style editing
Studio: Select area and Extend
What I like
Clean, readable text in images
Layerize text makes the words in an image editable
Ideogram 3.0 has style presets and colour palettes for brand work
Watch out for
Select area and Extend need a paid plan
Free images are public, and email-and-password accounts get no free credits
Canva is the Adobe Firefly alternative for people who make social posts, ads and presentations rather than art. Its AI tools sit in the same editor as its templates, so you can fix an image and finish the design without leaving Canva.
Canva's AI photo tools line up neatly with Firefly's (Canva):
Magic Edit: add, replace or tweak any part of an image with a text prompt. This is Canva's version of Generative Fill.
Magic Expand: extend a photo beyond its frame, like Firefly's Generative Expand.
Magic Eraser: remove anything unwanted from a photo.
Magic Grab: select a person or object in a photo so you can move or resize it.
Canva AI can also generate new photos from a prompt. And Canva owns Leonardo, number 2 on this list, though the two still run as separate products.
Canva pricing
Free: up to 20 uses of Canva's Standard or Premium AI tools a month.
Pro: $144 a year for one person, with up to 200 Premium AI uses (or 20 Ultra AI uses) a month and a free trial.
Business: $250 a year per person, with up to 400 Premium AI uses a month (Canva pricing).
Best for
Social posts, ads and slides
Price
Free plan; Pro $144/year
Firefly-style editing
Magic Edit and Magic Expand
What I like
Edit the image and finish the design in the same place
Thousands of templates for social posts, ads and slides
The free plan includes some AI uses
Watch out for
AI uses are capped, even on Pro
Magic Expand can struggle with faces, hands and transparent backgrounds, Canva says
ComfyUI is the best free Adobe Firefly alternative if you've got a decent computer. It's free, open-source software (GPL-3.0) that runs AI image models on your own machine, so there are no credits, no subscription and nothing leaves your computer.
ComfyUI runs most of the big open models: Stable Diffusion (SDXL and SD 3.5), FLUX.1 and FLUX.2, Qwen Image, Z-Image and HiDream, plus editing models like Flux Kontext and Qwen Image Edit. Inpainting and outpainting are built in, which covers what Firefly's Generative Fill and Generative Expand do (ComfyUI on GitHub).
You build each job as a flow of connected boxes called nodes, which looks scary at first. Ready-made templates and thousands of community workflows mean you rarely have to start from scratch: load an inpainting workflow, drop in your image and prompt, and run it.
There's a desktop app for Windows and macOS, and Linux users can install it manually. It works with NVIDIA, AMD, Intel and Apple Silicon chips, and ComfyUI says it can run large models on as little as 4GB of graphics memory and 8GB of RAM.
No good graphics card? Comfy Cloud runs ComfyUI in your browser on Comfy's own GPUs. Partner Nodes also let you call paid models like Nano Banana and ChatGPT Images from inside ComfyUI using credits (Comfy).
ComfyUI pricing
On your own computer: free.
Comfy Cloud Standard: $20/month ($16/month billed yearly), with 5 free runs to try it first.
Comfy Cloud Creator and Pro: $35/month ($28 yearly) and $100/month ($80 yearly) for more GPU time.
Best for
Free, private image work
Price
Free on your own PC; cloud from $20/month
Firefly-style editing
Built-in inpainting and outpainting
What I like
Free forever on your own computer
Runs almost every open image model, with inpainting and outpainting
Nothing you make leaves your machine
Watch out for
The node editor has a real learning curve
Needs a capable graphics card, or a Comfy Cloud plan
Each model has its own licence, so check commercial use before you sell anything you make
The right Adobe Firefly alternative comes down to what you make:
If you...
Pick
Want the best-looking images
Midjourney
Want a free plan and lots of editing tools
Leonardo
Already use ChatGPT
ChatGPT Images
Want free photo edits from a simple prompt
Google Gemini
Need clean text on posters, logos or thumbnails
Ideogram
Make social posts, ads and presentations
Canva
Want it free and private, on your own computer
ComfyUI
Need commercially safe images, or already pay for Photoshop
Stick with Adobe Firefly
Why use an Adobe Firefly alternative?
People switch from Adobe Firefly for better image quality, lower costs, more variety and more control over where their images are made.
Image quality: when I tested them side by side, Midjourney and Leonardo made more interesting images than Firefly's own model, which can look a bit bland. Firefly now includes partner models like Nano Banana and GPT Image, which narrows the gap.
Cost: Firefly's free plan is a daily allowance, and premium features like video use up your generative credits. Gemini, Leonardo and ComfyUI all do Firefly-style edits for free.
You don't use Adobe apps: if you're not already in Photoshop or Creative Cloud, Firefly is one more subscription for something other tools do well.
Variety: Adobe trains its own models only on licensed and public domain content, and it has a heavy content filter, so prompts about celebrities and other touchy topics don't work and the range of styles is narrower.
Privacy and control: Firefly runs in Adobe's cloud. ComfyUI runs open models on your own computer.
When should you stick with Adobe Firefly instead of switching?
Stick with Adobe Firefly if you already pay for Photoshop or Creative Cloud, or you need images your company can use commercially without legal worries. Adobe's own models are trained on licensed content, enterprise customers get IP indemnification, and Generative Fill is built right into Photoshop.
What is Adobe Firefly?
Adobe Firefly is Adobe's generative AI app for images, video and audio, released in 2023. It's best known for Generative Fill, which adds, removes or changes part of an image from a text prompt, and it powers the same feature in Photoshop.
Firefly Generative Fill (GIF: Adobe)
Firefly runs Adobe's own Firefly Image 5 model alongside partner models from Google, OpenAI, Black Forest Labs (FLUX), Runway and others, on the web and in apps for iOS and Android (Adobe). Adobe's own models are trained on licensed content like Adobe Stock plus public domain images, and Adobe pays Stock contributors whose work was used (Adobe). The partner models aren't covered by Adobe's commercially safe promise.
Firefly has a free plan with daily generations. Paid Firefly plans start at $9.99 a month and come with 2,000 to 50,000 generative credits a month, unlimited standard image features like Generative Fill, and access to partner models. Every Photoshop plan includes some monthly generative credits too.
What other Adobe Firefly alternatives are worth a look?
Runway, Recraft and Krea are worth a look if you need something more specific than an all-round image tool.
Runway: the pick if your Firefly work is mostly AI video content. Its Aleph model adds, removes and changes things in existing footage from a text prompt, which is like generative fill for video, and Gen-4.5 makes new clips. You get 125 free one-time credits, then Standard is $15 a month ($12 billed yearly) (Runway).
Recraft: makes vector images as well as regular ones, which suits logos, icons and brand graphics. Its newest models are the V4 generation. Free plan images are owned by Recraft, shown in its public gallery and not licensed for commercial use (Recraft).
Krea: draws images in real time as you sketch, and its editor gives you 10 editing models, including Nano Banana, Flux Kontext and Qwen. The free plan gives you 100 compute units a day.
Who should use Adobe Firefly alternatives?
Anyone who wants AI images or Firefly-style edits without an Adobe subscription, or who wants better results than Firefly gives them, should try these alternatives.
That covers creatives looking for ideas, businesses saving time and money on images and logos, freelancers selling their work, teachers making learning materials and anyone who just wants to fix a photo.
If you're mainly after image generation, my list of Midjourney alternatives covers even more options.
Wrapping up
Midjourney is still my pick for the best Adobe Firefly alternative, thanks to its image quality and the Vary Region tool in its web Editor. Leonardo is a close second and has a free plan. If you want Firefly-style edits for free, start with Google Gemini, or ComfyUI if you'd rather run everything on your own computer.
Yes, partly. Firefly has a free plan with a daily allowance of generations, and paid plans (Standard, Pro, Pro Plus and Premium) start at $9.99 a month and add 2,000 to 50,000 generative credits a month. See Adobe's Firefly plans for prices in your currency.
What is the best free Adobe Firefly alternative?
+
Google Gemini for quick edits, Leonardo for a full editor, and ComfyUI if you want it free forever on your own computer. Gemini's free Nano Banana 2 model edits photos from a simple prompt, Leonardo's free plan gives you 150 tokens a day, and ComfyUI is free, open-source software that runs models like FLUX and Qwen Image locally.
What apps are similar to Adobe Firefly?
+
Midjourney, Leonardo, ChatGPT Images, Google Gemini, Ideogram, Canva and ComfyUI are the apps most similar to Adobe Firefly. All of them make images from a text prompt and let you change part of an image, like Firefly's Generative Fill. Runway is the closest match for Firefly's video tools.
Who are the main Adobe Firefly competitors?
+
The main Adobe Firefly competitors are Midjourney, Leonardo, OpenAI's ChatGPT Images, Google's Nano Banana in Gemini, Ideogram and Canva, with Runway competing on video. Midjourney leads on image quality, Leonardo on value, Gemini on free edits and Ideogram on text. Some of them, like Google's Nano Banana, OpenAI's GPT Image and Runway, are also offered as partner models inside Firefly.
Which is better, Canva or Adobe Firefly?
+
Canva is better for social posts, ads and presentations, and Adobe Firefly is better for generating and editing images. Canva puts AI tools like Magic Edit and Magic Expand next to its templates, with 20 AI uses a month on the free plan. Firefly is a dedicated generative AI app with Generative Fill, Adobe's commercially safe models and partner models like Nano Banana.
Is Adobe Firefly the best AI image generator?
+
No, not for image quality, but it's the safest pick for commercial work. Midjourney makes better-looking images and Google's Nano Banana is better at quick photo edits. Firefly wins on Adobe's own models, which are trained on licensed and public domain content, and on Generative Fill being built into Photoshop.
What is the best Adobe Firefly generative fill alternative?
+
Midjourney's web Editor is the best Adobe Firefly generative fill alternative. Its Vary Region tool lets you erase part of an image and regenerate it with a prompt, on Midjourney images or your own uploads. For free, Gemini's Nano Banana 2 model edits photos from a text prompt, and ComfyUI has inpainting and outpainting built in.
Is there a free open-source alternative to Adobe Firefly?
+
Yes. ComfyUI is free, open-source software (GPL-3.0) that runs image models like Stable Diffusion, FLUX and Qwen Image on your own computer, with inpainting and outpainting built in. ComfyUI says it can run large models on as little as 4GB of graphics memory, and Comfy Cloud runs it in your browser from $20 a month if your computer can't.
Does Midjourney have generative fill like Adobe Firefly?
+
Yes. Midjourney's Editor on midjourney.com lets you erase part of an image and regenerate it with a prompt (Vary Region), extend the canvas, and edit your own uploaded photos. Its V8 Edit model can also change images from written instructions.
Can ChatGPT edit images like Photoshop's Generative Fill?
+
Yes. In ChatGPT Images you can highlight part of an image with the selection tool and describe what to change, or just describe the edit in chat. It works on images ChatGPT made and on photos you upload.
How much does Midjourney cost?
+
$10 a month for the Basic plan. Standard is $30, Pro is $60 and Mega is $120 a month, and paying yearly takes 20% off. There's no free plan.